Skip to content
Independent reporting

DOJ Drops Alaska Senate Case—Then Moves to Vacate Dismissal

Share X Facebook Email

The Justice Department has moved to drop its lawsuit over Alaska’s U.S. Senate certification, telling the Ninth Circuit the dispute is now “moot,” according to ABC News’ report on a Thursday filing from DOJ official Stanley Woodward. At the same time, DOJ asked the appeals court to vacate the district court order that dismissed the case.

Why DOJ says the case is over

ABC News reports the filing states, “This Court should deny the motion to summarily affirm the district court’s judgment. Instead, this Court should vacate the district court’s order dismissing this lawsuit, because the case has become moot.”

stream logo
Image source: abcnews.com · Source

Later in the brief, Woodward wrote that the United States “reluctantly acknowledges that there no longer exists any means of ‘determin[ing] whether votes cast for Daniel J. Sullivan were meant to be cast for Senator Sullivan’ and vindicating the United States’ asserted injury,” per ABC News’ account of the filing.

How the fight began

Before Election Day, President Donald Trump directed DOJ to preemptively sue to block certification of Alaska’s Senate race if Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan lost, citing potential name confusion with candidate Dan J. Sullivan, ABC News reported. Republicans had alleged Dan J. Sullivan ran a sham campaign to confuse voters and siphon votes from Sen. Dan S. Sullivan; those are allegations reported by ABC News.

What the courts did

A federal judge in Alaska dismissed DOJ’s suit on Nov. 1, finding “no workable plan” to investigate the name-confusion claims in relation to ballots already submitted, according to ABC News. DOJ’s new filing asks the Ninth Circuit to vacate that dismissal while acknowledging the dispute is not worth further litigation because it is moot.

Image source: abcnews.com · Source
Image source: abcnews.com · Source
Image source: abcnews.com · Source

Where the race stands

The Associated Press projected Tuesday that Democrat Mary Peltola will win the Alaska Senate race, which ABC News described as the ninth Senate pickup for Democrats in the next Congress. ABC News also reported that, in recent days, Trump called for Alaska’s results to be ruled in favor of Sen. Sullivan by combining votes for Dan J. Sullivan and another Republican candidate he alleged was unlawfully recruited by Democrats as a spoiler; those are Trump’s allegations as relayed by ABC News.

Share X Facebook Email

The Verified Brief

The day’s essential headlines, without the noise.

A concise briefing delivered directly to your inbox.

Free to join. Unsubscribe any time.

Powered by Reach Response